Whitelaw Twining
  • Firm
  • Expertise
  • Our Team
  • Updates
    • Firm News
    • Publications
    • Community
    • Commercial Litigation Blog
  • Careers
    • Overview
    • Students
    • Lawyers & Staff
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • 24/7 Response

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Home — Updates —

Over $9 million awarded in Personal Injury Action involving Winter Road Conditions

11 04 2020
Share:
FacebookTwitterLinkedInEmail

Uy v Dhillon, 2020 BCSC 1302

The BC Supreme Court recently awarded to date the highest damages in a personal injury claim, with an award totaling $9.2 million. The claim involved a highway rear-ender that occurred on January 31, 2014 on the Coquihalla Highway in British Columbia. The plaintiff Johnberlyn Uy was driving in the fast lane of a 3-lane section of the highway. A tractor-trailer combination driven by the defendant Daljit Singh Dhillon changed lanes into Mr. Uy’s pathway while passing a slower moving tractor-trailer. Mr. Uy unsuccessfully attempted to avoid the collision and struck the rear of Mr. Dhillion’s tractor trailer.   

Mr. Uy brought an action against Mr. Dhillon as well as against the provincial road maintenance contractor, VSA Highway Maintenance Ltd. Before trial, VSA was released as the evidence confirmed that at the time of the accident the highway had been properly maintained. At trial, the Court found Mr. Dhillon 100% liable on the basis that Mr. Dhillon had failed to check for approaching vehicles before making a lane change. The Court of Appeal upheld the ruling. 

On damages, the Court found the accident had rendered the 39-year old Plaintiff catastrophically injured. He suffered a left frontal skull fracture and a severe brain injury causing serious cognitive impairment that included memory loss, significant disorientation and severe mood changes. He was unable to live independently, could not hold a job as a construction laborer and required assistance and supervision while doing most daily tasks. 

The Court awarded upper non-pecuniary damage limits in the amount of $388,177 to reflect the profoundness and permanency of Mr. Uy’s brain injury. Future care costs were assessed at over $7.2 million to provide for daily professional nurse aid while Mr. Uy stayed in his family’s care for 15 years, and thereafter to pay for a private care home for the remainder of Mr. Uy’s life. He was also awarded damages for home safety accessories, rehabilitation and occupational therapy services. Past income loss  was assessed at $172,000, with future income loss assessed at $600,000.  An In Trust claim of $700,000 was also awarded to Mr. Uy’s family as well as $150,000 in special damages and $245,000 for the Ministry’s Health Care Cost Claim.  Further awards for tax gross up and management fees were left to be assessed at a later date. 

Should you have any questions or require further information, please contact Daniel Shugarman.

Key Contact

  • Daniel Shugarman
    Country Managing Partner
    604 891 7243
    dshugarman@wt.ca

Authors

  • Carolien Geiger

Expertise

  • Road Maintenance
Previous
Back
Next
Whitelaw Twining

Vancouver
2400 200 Granville Street
Vancouver, BC V6C 1S4
1 866 982 9898
604 682 5466
contact@wt.ca

Calgary
810 150 9th Ave SW
Calgary, AB  T2P 3H9
403 775 2200
contact@wt.ca

Toronto
1100 123 Front Street West
Toronto, ON M5J 2M2
647 805 8470
contact@wt.ca

24/7 Emergency Line
1 778 558 0641

DWF
  • paper airplane icon Newsletter
  • LinkedIn iconLinkedIn
  • icon of arrow pointing rightCareers
  • icon of arrow pointing rightContact
  • icon of arrow pointing right24/7 Response
  • Firm
  • Expertise
  • People
  • Firm News
Disclaimer Privacy Policy

2023 © WT BCA LLP. All Rights Reserved. WT BCA LLP is a limited liability partnership consisting of lawyers regulated by the Law Society of British Columbia and others, that provides services in accordance with a letter issued by the Law Society of British Columbia, which may be viewed here.